

Necessary, Not Sufficient

Guest Writer
The first iteration of the “Recommended Minimum Training Guidelines for Telecommunicators,” released in 2016, was a collaborative first effort from 911 industry leaders to establish a national baseline competency for telecommunicator training. However, some centers (as well as politicians) treated these guidelines as a complete training standard rather than the initial baseline they were intended to be.
As this document was being revised in preparation for its re-release, the International Academies of Emergency Dispatch® (IAED™) sought to more accurately reflect the critical role of Emergency Dispatchers and the knowledge and capabilities essential to serving the public.
Over the past two years, the IAED specifically aimed to modify the title of these guidelines, clarify definitions, create visual representations, and include clear cautions that “minimum” training is necessary but not sufficient to fully prepare Emergency Dispatchers to take on-line 911 calls.
Emphasis on “initial”
These efforts included the title itself: “Recommended Minimum Guidelines for Initial Public Safety Telecommunicator Training."
The use of the word “initial” sets a conscious limitation on these entry-level guidelines, which were never meant to fill seats at the console without discipline-specific instruction and certification. In fact, that notion creates a gaping vulnerability.
Even in 1979, as Emergency Medical Dispatcher (EMD) training courses were first introduced, protocol inventor Dr. Jeff Clawson outlined the critical need for Emergency Dispatchers to complete the equivalent of advanced life-support level training in EMD (later extended to fire and police services). With little to no professional development prior to that emerging evolution, the IAED’s courses armed EMDs with critical field and protocol knowledge, strengthening what once was perceived as “the weak link” in the patient chain of survival.1
We can—and must—do better today. Just as one rotation in medical school does not give a physician the expertise to do heart surgery, initial minimum training does not prepare public safety telecommunicators to give CPR instructions, handle an active shooting, or guide a trapped individual in a burning building.2
As the new guidelines make clear, telecommunicators “trained only to the entry-level (pre-discipline specific) should never field or manage emergency calls in a live environment without successfully completing the appropriate discipline-specific training (Police, Fire, Medical).”
In each of these cases, the impact on human life is significant—potentially devastating. The bare minimum training should not be considered the full standard to meet. Rather, “initial public safety telecommunicator training” should serve only as a prerequisite for further discipline specific training and certification.

The Parthenon—a visual representation
As a visual representation of the foundation these guidelines create, we took inspiration from a famous Greek architectural structure to create “The Parthenon of Public Safety Telecommunications.” As illustrated in the image found on the next page, the foundation is comprised of “Initial Telecommunicator Training,” but the overall profession relies on columns of discipline specific certification training and ongoing professional education. These additional pillars of knowledge and capability are not considered optional, as they literally support the structure, and thus the overarching public safety telecommunicator profession.
Revised definition
Additionally, we suggested a revision to the definition of “Priority Dispatch Protocols,” which has long served as a clear and essential descriptor for this class of systems, rather than relying on the “dispatch-less” generic term “protocols.”
1.2.16 Priority Dispatch Protocols. A system of structured, logic-based, and scripted dispatch procedures, including systemized caller-interrogation questions, decision and logic pathways, and pre-arrival instructions, enabling discipline-certified Emergency Dispatchers to match a caller’s condition or situation to the correct public safety response level, then provide reproducible, prioritized, unbiased, and safe care consistent within the current standard of care and practice. Protocols, by definition, require direct, non-optional use, whenever possible and appropriate.
Big picture
These “Recommended Minimum Guidelines for Initial Public Safety Telecommunicator Training” don’t hold legislative power. There are no legal ramifications enforced and no standard that will be adopted without states and agencies choosing to “raise the roof,” so to speak.
So why do these guidelines matter for emergency communication centers, their staff, or especially our already-certified Emergency Dispatchers? The answer is in the compliant evaluative service and care instructions a caller receives when they dial those three digits.
When the stakes are planted with clear understanding that minimum training is only a necessary foundation, a career journey takes shape to prepare a confident, capable generation of student telecommunicators held to a higher standard, nationwide.
At the IAED, we believe the profession deserves more than minimum competency. Initial training may prepare someone to sit at the console, but discipline-specific certification prepares them to protect and improve lives. By building upon foundational training with rigorous police, fire, and medical certification, agencies ensure their student telecommunicators can deliver consistent, evidence-based, and lifesaving assistance when time matters most.
Initial telecommunicator training lays the foundation, but discipline-specific “post-graduate” training certification provides the structural support upon which the profession must stand and therefore its essential professionals can't practice “on-line” without it.
Sources
1. Clawson J. “Dispatch Priority Training: Strengthening The Weak Link.” Journal of EMS. 1981; 6:32–36.
2. Clawson J., Martin R.L., Lloyd B., Smith M., Cady G. “The EMD as a Medical Professional.” Journal of EMS. 1996; 21:69–72.




